Akash Jain

Search

Generalised symmetries

Hydrodynamics with higher-form and higher-group symmetries, from magnetohydrodynamics to topological defects.

Magnetohydrodynamics, or MHD, describes conducting fluids in strong magnetic fields: it couples hydrodynamics to Maxwell’s electromagnetism. Because there are no magnetic monopoles, magnetic field lines never end. This leads to a conservation principle: unless external sources act, magnetic field lines can be neither created nor destroyed.

This is an example of a higher-form or generalised symmetry. Ordinary symmetries act on point-like particles such as electrons; higher-form symmetries act on extended objects such as strings or surfaces. With collaborators, I have studied hydrodynamics with higher-form symmetries in general (arXiv:1803.00991) and shown that MHD itself is such a theory, with a spontaneously broken one-form symmetry (arXiv:1808.01939).

This formulation also makes resistive plasmas easier to simulate, without Ampère’s law. More recently, we have studied effective theories with higher-group symmetries, which combine symmetries of different form degrees, with an application to the bosonic M5 brane. We have also studied approximate higher-form symmetries, which describe topological defects and dynamical phase transitions.

Papers

  • Resistive relativistic magnetohydrodynamics without Ampère’s law

    R. Lier, A. Jain, J. Armas, O. Porth

    Jan 2025 PRD 2501.04638 INSPIRE

    Magnetic reconnection, where magnetic field lines in a plasma break and rejoin, powers flares and particle acceleration in high-energy astrophysics. It relies on the plasma’s small electrical resistance, which is hard to simulate: in the traditional description, Ampère’s law makes the equations “stiff” and forces tiny time steps. We drop Ampère’s law altogether, using a formulation of magnetohydrodynamics based on a higher-form symmetry in which resistivity acts like a magnetic viscosity, and build a causal numerical scheme that handles strong shocks moving near the speed of light.

    Density in a simulation of the relativistic Orszag–Tang vortex using one-form magnetohydrodynamics.
  • Higher-group global symmetry and the bosonic M5 brane

    J. Armas, G. Batzios, A. Jain

    Feb 2024 JHEP 2402.19458 INSPIRE

    Physicists classify phases of matter, such as magnets or superfluids, by which symmetries they break. The idea now extends to “higher-form” symmetries, whose charges are extended objects such as strings and membranes, and to “higher groups” that intertwine several of them. We show that such symmetries arise in supergravity, the low-energy limit of string and M-theory, when branes are present, and classify the phases they allow. For the bosonic M5-brane, a five-dimensional object in M-theory, all the fields living on it turn out to be ripples of broken symmetries, called Goldstone modes.

  • Approximate higher-form symmetries, topological defects, and dynamical phase transitions

    J. Armas, A. Jain

    Jan 2023 PRD 2301.09628 INSPIRE

    Higher-form symmetries, whose charges are extended objects such as magnetic field lines, help classify phases of matter. In real materials they are rarely exact: topological defects, such as vortices or charges on which field lines end, break them slightly. We build effective theories and hydrodynamics for such approximate higher-form symmetries and the ways they can be broken. The framework captures phase transitions driven by a proliferation of defects, from the melting of liquid crystals and the ionisation of a gas into a plasma to spin ice and the Meissner effect in superconductors.

    Strings crossing two surfaces, with red points where strings can end, illustrating an approximate higher-form symmetry.
  • One-form superfluids & magnetohydrodynamics

    J. Armas, A. Jain

    Nov 2018 JHEP 1811.04913 INSPIRE

    Magnetohydrodynamics, the theory of electrically conducting plasmas, describes everything from accretion disks around black holes to fusion reactors. We reformulate it using generalised symmetries, in which the fact that magnetic field lines never end becomes a symmetry, and show that magnetohydrodynamics is a “one-form superfluid” in which this symmetry is partly broken. Breaking it completely describes plasmas without free charges that can still be polarised, such as a neutral gas bathed in light, for which we build the first hydrodynamic theory. We also map out their equilibrium states.

    Map of the connections between one-form superfluids, string fluids, magnetohydrodynamics and related theories.
  • Magnetohydrodynamics as superfluidity

    J. Armas, A. Jain

    Aug 2018 PRL 1808.01939 INSPIRE

    Magnetohydrodynamics describes how plasmas and magnetic fields move together, in stars and galaxies as well as in fusion experiments. We show that it can be recast as a new kind of superfluid. Magnetic field lines never end, since there are no magnetic monopoles, and this can be viewed as a “one-form” symmetry; in a plasma the symmetry is spontaneously broken, with a magnetic scalar potential as its Goldstone mode. This writes magnetohydrodynamics purely as conservation equations, better suited to simulations, and settles how its equilibrium states should be defined.

    Magnetic field lines inside a slowly rotating magnetised star: straight and parallel when the rotation and magnetic axes are aligned, denser and skewed towards the edges when they are misaligned.
  • Dissipative hydrodynamics with higher-form symmetry

    J. Armas, J. Gath, A. Jain, A. V. Pedersen

    Mar 2018 JHEP 1803.00991 INSPIRE

    In ordinary fluids, conserved quantities are carried by particles. In some systems they are carried by extended objects such as strings or membranes; in a plasma, magnetic field lines behave like conserved strings. We build the theory of dissipative fluids filled with such objects, which flow differently along and across them, and identify all the transport coefficients, such as viscosities and resistivities, that characterise them at leading order. We also describe interfaces between phases of such fluids, where ripples on the surface show clear signs of the fluid’s directionality.

    Charges of ordinary and higher-form symmetries: point particles counted in a volume, strings counted where they cross a surface, and membranes counted where they cross a line.

Talks

Higher-form symmetries and topological phase transitions

Armas, Jain 2023

  • The Many Faces of Relativistic Fluid Dynamics Workshop, KITP, UC Santa Barbara, USA

    Conference talk Recording Slides

  • Eurostrings 2023, Gijón, Spain

    Conference talk Slides

  • University of Oxford, UK

    Slides

  • Holography: Triangle Meeting, Delta Institute for Theoretical Physics, Netherlands

    Slides

  • Beyond Lorentzian Geometry II Workshop, University of Edinburgh, UK

    Conference talk Slides

  • University of Southampton, UK

    Slides

Generalised global symmetries and magnetohydrodynamics

Armas et al. 2018 Armas, Jain 2018a Armas, Jain 2018b Armas, Jain 2019

  • Université Libre de Bruxelles, Belgium

    Slides

  • Autonomous University of Madrid, Spain

    Slides

  • University of Barcelona, Spain

    Slides

  • Utrecht University, Netherlands

    Slides

  • École Polytechnique, France

    Slides

  • Perimeter Institute for Theoretical Physics, Canada

    Talk and recording

  • University of British Columbia, Canada

    Slides

  • Harish-Chandra Research Institute, Allahabad, India

    Slides

  • IISER Bhopal, India

    Slides

  • Tata Institute of Fundamental Research, Mumbai, India

    Slides

  • IISER Pune, India

    Slides

Generalised global symmetries and viscoelastic hydrodynamics

Armas, Jain 2018b Armas, Jain 2019

  • Hydrodynamics at All Length Scales Workshop, Lorentz Center, Netherlands

    Conference talk Slides